Collaborative Discussion
Major themes in literature often relate back to the idea of “good vs. evil.” For example, in novels you can often find a brave hero facing off against a wicked villain to teach the reader that being good and doing the right thing is what is best for society. These stories usually show the hero as being all good and the villain as being all bad, and the choice to do the right thing is always very clear. However, how does this apply to the real world?
The article, “A teen and a trolley reveal society’s dark side,” explores this debate. Examine the article and determine whether you believe that people can be completely good or whether you think there is a dark side to us all. Explain your reasoning.
I believe that the idea of people being completely good or having a dark side is not a binary concept, but rather a spectrum. People are capable of both good and bad actions, depending on the circumstances they find themselves in. The article discusses a situation where a group of people must make a decision to sacrifice one person in order to save five others. This ethical dilemma forces them to confront their own moral values and question whether they are truly good or have a dark side within them.
In the real world, people are constantly faced with ethical dilemmas where they must make difficult decisions that may not have a clear answer. While some individuals may consistently choose to do the right thing and prioritize the greater good, others may prioritize their own self-interests or act out of fear and insecurity. This complexity of human nature demonstrates that everyone has the capacity for both good and evil within them.
Furthermore, societal influences, personal experiences, and individual beliefs all play a role in shaping one's moral compass. The idea of "good vs. evil" is not always black and white, but rather shades of grey that can be influenced by a variety of factors. Ultimately, I believe that it is important for individuals to reflect on their actions, consider the consequences of their choices, and strive to act in ways that align with their values and principles.