Why does the executive branch at each level of government begin the budget-making process?

The executive branch at each level of government begins the budget-making process for several reasons:

1. Constitutional Responsibility: In many democratic systems, the executive branch, led by the president or governor, is constitutionally responsible for initiating the budget process. This responsibility is often mentioned in the respective constitutions, providing the executive branch with the authority and mandate to create and present budgets.

2. Expertise and Resources: The executive branch, especially at the top level, possesses the necessary expertise and resources to analyze the national, state, or local economy, financial situation, and public needs. They have access to economic advisors, financial experts, and data, enabling them to generate informed and comprehensive budget proposals.

3. Policy Priorities: The executive branch represents the ruling government and its policy priorities. By initiating the budget process, they can align the budget with their strategic goals, political agenda, and promises made during the election campaign. It allows them to allocate resources and funds according to their priorities, addressing key issues like healthcare, education, infrastructure, defense, etc.

4. Executive Accountability: As the executive branch is responsible for the day-to-day administration and governance of the country or region, initiating the budget process creates a sense of accountability. It enables them to take ownership of the budget, defend it before the legislature and the public, and be held responsible for the financial decisions made.

5. Efficiency and Timeliness: Starting the budget-making process from the executive branch ensures efficiency and timely execution. They have the administrative capacity and institutional framework to collect, analyze, and compile data, consult with various stakeholders, and craft a budget proposal within a specific timeframe. It also facilitates coordination between different departments and agencies to streamline the process.

While the executive branch begins the budget-making process, it is important to note that the final budget is subject to legislative approval. The legislative branch, represented by the parliament or legislature, reviews, amends, and ultimately approves the budget, ensuring checks and balances in the budgetary process.