reply in pronouns
as-tu donné des papiers a tes amis a l'école?
tu leur y en as donné
is this right?
or is it
tu les leur y as donnés
Because it is "des papiers" = en and à l'école = y and à tes amis = leur you replaced everything correctly the first time. Then just remember it is:
le lui
la > > y > en + vb
les leur
This particular sentence does not have a direct-object pronoun.
Tu leur y en as donné.
Sra (aka Mme)
merci beaucoup!
Both sentences have minor errors. The correct sentence in pronouns would be:
"Les leur en as-tu donnés ?"
Let's break down the sentence to understand why it is correct:
1. "Les" is used as the direct object pronoun, replacing "des papiers," which means "papers" in English. Since it is plural, we use "les" instead of "le" or "la."
2. "Leur" is used as the indirect object pronoun, replacing "à tes amis," which means "to your friends" in English. Since it is plural, we use "leur" instead of "lui."
3. "En" is used to replace the prepositional phrase "à l'école," which means "at school" in English.
4. "As-tu" is the correct word order for a question. It means "Have you given?"
5. "Donnés" agrees with the direct object "papiers" (papers), so it needs to be plural and masculine.
Therefore, the correct sentence would be:
"Les leur en as-tu donnés ?"