The sightings reported by Winthrop and others in 1639 and 1644 remain a mystery to this day. While some explanations have been offered, none have been able to fully explain the strange lights and objects witnessed in the sky.
Whether it was a natural phenomenon, an optical illusion, or something else entirely, the sightings remain a fascinating piece of history. And while UFO sightings are more commonly associated with the modern era, it's interesting to note that reports of unidentified flying objects have been around for centuries.
Perhaps one day, advances in science and technology will offer a clearer explanation for what was seen that day in 17th century Massachusetts. Until then, the sightings described by Winthrop and others will continue to be a curious and intriguing part of our history.