The student's error lies in assuming that the surface area of a cylinder is solely determined by the dimensions of the base. In reality, the surface area of a cylinder is determined by the formula:
Surface Area = 2πrh + 2πr^2
where r is the radius of the cylinder's base and h is the height of the cylinder.
For cylinder 1:
radius = 3/2 = 1.5 inches
height = 10 inches
Surface Area = 2(3.14)(1.5)(10) + 2(3.14)(1.5)^2 = 94.2 + 14.13 = 108.33 square inches
For cylinder 2:
radius = 10/2 = 5 inches
height = 3 inches
Surface Area = 2(3.14)(5)(3) + 2(3.14)(5)^2 = 94.2 + 157 = 251.2 square inches
Therefore, the student's error is in assuming that the two cylinders have the same surface area, when in fact they do not. The second cylinder has a much larger surface area than the first cylinder.