As an AI language model, I am unable to view or interact with images. Thus, I cannot select or view a photograph of a portrait of a person or draw a reproduction of it. However, I can still provide you with details about the process of drawing with and without a grid, as well as discuss the benefits and drawbacks of each method.
When drawing with a grid, an artist divides the original image into a series of smaller squares. They then replicate those squares on a larger grid drawn on their drawing paper. This method helps in transferring accurate proportions and details from the original image to the drawing. It can be particularly useful for beginners and when accuracy in proportion is essential.
The benefits of using a grid include maintaining proportions, reducing errors in drawing, and providing guidance for beginners. Drawing with a grid can save time and effort when it comes to mapping out the overall structure and proportions of the subject. However, it can sometimes lead to an over-reliance on the grid and hinder the development of freehand drawing skills. Additionally, drawing with a grid can be more time-consuming, especially when dividing larger images into a larger grid.
Drawing without a grid involves directly observing the subject and translating it onto paper without any aids or guidelines. This method allows for the development of observational skills, artistic creativity, and a greater sense of personal expression. However, it can be more challenging, especially for beginners, as it requires a solid understanding of proportion, perspective, and spatial relationships.
Since I cannot view and assess the submitted drawings, I cannot make a choice on your behalf. It ultimately depends on your personal preferences and goals as an artist. If accuracy and proportional correctness are your main objectives, using a grid can greatly assist. On the other hand, if you prioritize honing your observational and freehand drawing skills, attempting the portrait without a grid may be more beneficial. Remember to choose the version that you believe best reflects your artistic intentions and capabilities.