7. Suppose there are two possible income distributions in a society of ten people. In the first distribution, nine people have incomes of $30,000 and one person has an income of $10,000. In the second distribution, all ten people have incomes of $25,000.
a. If the society had the first income distribution, what would be the utilitarian argument for redistributing income?
The nine individuals have a higher utility than the one individual with the income of $10,000. So if for example a dollar was taken from the rich and given to the poor the utility of society as a whole would increase. This is because the poor person would have a higher utility from the dollar gained than the fall in utility from the rich people.
b. Which income distribution would Rawls consider more equitable? Explain.
I would think that the second distribution would be more equitable since Rawls would want equality.
c. Which income distribution would Nozick consider more equitable? Explain.
I would think that Nozick would consider the first distribution more equitable. Since Nozick would want individuals to a fair playing field but not concerned about the resulting distribution of income. So the second distribution of income is equal so the only option left is the first one.
What is your question regarding this situation?
I would like to know if my responses for each of the 3 questions is correct.
Your bottom line answers for Utilitarians and Rawls are correct. However, both views have exceptions which you should note in your final answer.
Nozick, on the other hand, is not bothered by income inequality as long as the process for generating the distribution is "fair." So, Nozick would not "prefer" either distribution. However, he would not advocate a redistribution process that moves from distribution a to distribution b.
Bottom line. your are on the right track; but your arguments need to be much more fully developed; certainly more than a single sentence for each.
Answer this Question
world history pls pls help help
What did special religious observances in both the Aztec and Spanish calendars provide for people? Work and income Education and training Law and justice Fun and entertainment is it d pls help
Having a hard time in World History! Please let me know if these are right and if not please tell me the answers! 1. How did the religious beliefs of the ancient Israelites differ from those of other nearby peoples? The Israelites believed in many gods,
1. How did the religious beliefs of the ancient Israelites differ from those of other nearby peoples? The Israelites believed in many gods, while other peoples believed in only one God.*** The Israelites believed in one God, while other peoples believed in
A man spends 1/5 of his income on food and 1/3 of the remainder on his car.If he then has 286.00 left what is his income
Explain how each of the following people would talk about scarcity and trade-offs. a) The President of the United States: b) The leader of a developing nation. c) A U.S. citizen whose income is in the top one percent. d) A U.S. citizen whose income is in
The gross income of Ginger Hughes is $215 per week. Her deductions are: $15.16, FICA tax; $29.33, income tax; 2% state tax; 1% city tax; and 3% retirement fund. What is her net income?
Which of the following was one of the influences of the Roman Republic on the framing of the constitution? A. A centralized gov. that provides for more order. B. Elected representatives who are the voice of the people. C. A judicial system that is
A work team of four people completes half a job in 15 days. How many days will it take a team of ten people to complete the remaining half of the job? (Assume that each person of both teams works at the same rate as each of the other people.) I just would
he pie chart below shows how the total annual income for a certain family is spent. If the amount budgeted for Housing and Insurance combined is 42,000, what is the total family income? there is saving 8%, food 19%, clothing 18%, auto 12%, entertainment
6. Carlos loves to spend time with his younger brother. Even though he is busy with school and work, Carlos always makes time for them to do things together what is this an example of? a. honesty b. justice c. priorities *** d. media 7. What is it called