1. He was surprised she came at all.

2. He was surprised she came after all.

3. He was surprised she came anyway.

4. He was surprised she came any how.

5. He was surprised she came at any rate.

6. He was surprised she came at all events.
--------------------------
Does #1 mean #2 in meaning?
Which pharases are commonly used?
The other things seem to have the same meaning.

All are OK.

1, 2, and 3 are the most commonly used.

4, 5, and 6 seem about the same, but are not usual.

1. "He was surprised she came at all": This phrase means that the person speaking was surprised that the other person came, even though they weren't expecting them to come at all.

2. "He was surprised she came after all": This phrase means that the person speaking was surprised the other person came, despite doubts or previously expressed skepticism about their arrival.

The phrases #1 and #2 do not have the exact same meaning. While both indicate surprise at the person's arrival, #1 suggests that there was no expectation for the person to come at all, whereas #2 suggests that there were doubts or prior skepticism about their arrival.

Out of the phrases given, #1 and #2 are more commonly used.

#3 and #6 have similar meanings, indicating surprise despite some circumstances or obstacles. They can be used interchangeably, but #3 is more commonly used.

#4 and #5 are less common and may not be used in everyday conversation. They can be interpreted as indicating surprise regardless of the specific way or manner in which the person arrived.